← Back to Blog

5 Costly Mistakes When Choosing a Real Estate Agent

When buying or selling a home, choosing the wrong agent can cost you thousands of dollars and months of frustration. After 23 years as a licensed Realtor, I've seen these mistakes happen over and over again. Here are the five most expensive errors people make:

Mistake #1: Picking an Agent from a Yard Sign

That "For Sale" sign in your neighbor's yard might seem convenient, but it tells you nothing about the agent's qualifications, availability, or track record. Just because they listed one house in your neighborhood doesn't mean they're the right fit for your specific needs.

The Hidden Cost: You might end up with an agent who specializes in luxury homes when you need someone experienced with first-time buyers, or vice versa.

Mistake #2: Going with "Whoever a Friend Recommends"

Your friend's agent might have been perfect for their situation, but that doesn't guarantee they're right for yours. What worked for someone selling a starter home might not work for someone buying a luxury property or relocating from out of state.

The Hidden Cost: Mismatched expertise can lead to pricing mistakes, missed opportunities, and transactions that fall through.

Mistake #3: Not Asking About Availability and Response Time

Many people assume all agents are equally available, but this couldn't be further from the truth. Some agents juggle 20+ clients, others work part-time, and some disappear for days during critical moments.

The Hidden Cost: When your agent is unreachable during negotiations or inspection deadlines, deals can collapse entirely.

Mistake #4: Focusing Only on Commission Rates

Choosing an agent based solely on the lowest commission is like choosing a surgeon based on price. The cheapest option often costs the most in the long run through poor marketing, weak negotiation, or extended time on market.

The Hidden Cost: A discount agent who prices your home wrong or fails to market effectively can cost you tens of thousands more than you'd save on commission.

Mistake #5: Not Verifying Track Record and Specialization

Not all real estate agents are created equal. Some excel at luxury properties, others at first-time buyers, some at relocations, and others at investment properties. Failing to match the agent's expertise to your specific situation is a recipe for problems.

The Hidden Cost: An agent without experience in your transaction type may miss important details, fail to anticipate problems, or lack the specialized knowledge needed for success.

The Solution: Professional Agent Matching

This is exactly why I created my agent matching service. Instead of leaving this crucial decision to chance, I use a comprehensive system to understand your specific needs and match you with agents who specialize in exactly what you're buying or selling.

The right agent match can mean the difference between a smooth transaction and a costly nightmare. Don't let these common mistakes derail one of the biggest financial decisions of your life.

Find Your Perfect Agent Match

Let me use my 23 years of experience and comprehensive 22-question evaluation system to match you with the perfect agent for your specific needs.

Get Started Free

Call: 267-210-8713

About the Author

David Najdzinowicz is a RE/MAX Hall of Fame recipient with over 23 years of experience in real estate. He has helped hundreds of clients nationwide find the right real estate agent for their specific needs through his professional matching service at RecommendAgent.com. With more than 130 five-star reviews, David continues to provide expert guidance to buyers and sellers across the United States.